OBJECTIVES & REQUIREMENTS
The Seminar
The focus is mostly on images of women in pre-Christian societies in prehistoric Europe and in the Eastern Mediterranean (Ancient Egypt, Palestine, Crete, and Greece), with some attention also given to the Celts and other "barbarian" peoples.
Among the issues to be examined are the perceived place and status of women in ancient societies, the controversial debate over the possible existence of matrilineal social structures in the early historical period in the Eastern Mediterranean, Genesis and Old Testament patriarchy, the nature and identity of female deities, symbols of the female, Amazons, maenads, hetairai, and female sexuality in the ancient world.
Views
It is a fact that the Prehistoric and Ancient worlds have been excavated and examined largely by men who interpreted what they discovered from a "western" white male point of view. Today there is a willingness to acknowledge that other views exist and that they can offer equally valid interpretations of the past.
The interpretation of the Prehistoric and Ancient past in male terms is being challenged these days by feminists. If women have views today, then women in the Prehistoric and Ancient past may also have had views, and ideas, and attitudes, and concerns, which may be reflected, contained, or directly represented in art. These, if they exist, have been overlooked because the male observer or researcher is not predisposed on the basis of sex to recognize them.
The task of reinterpretation is made difficult by the depth to which male views are embedded "western" culture. It is necessary to remind ourselves that the "past is a foreign country" and guard against interpreting the past in the light of our own contemporary views. Even well-meaning feminist researchers bent of recovering lost female identities are weighed down by the baggage of their own culture.
In this seminar we will try to seek out the presence of women in the art of the Prehistoric and Ancient worlds. We will attempt to identify alternative "female, non-western" points of view and test them out in interpretations of images of women in Prehistoric and Ancient in art.
This approach will not only generate new views, but will also revive discredited views, such as the possibility that matrilineal cultures prevailed in the prehistoric period and continued into the historical period.
At the same time, however, we must guard against the desire to substitute new views for the old ones. The point is not to substitute an interpretation we like for one we don't like, to replace a male view with a female view, but to broaden and enrich our range of views, and to acknowledge both the existance and the validity of other ways of seeing and interpreting images of women in Prehistoric and Ancient art.
Exploration
The alternative views, and the questions they generate, are to be understood as the basis for further critical analysis that goes beyond familiar material.
One of the aims of the seminar is to develop the ability to become aware of alternative views and to formulate new questions based upon a critical appreciation of those views. The seminar asks you to consider the known, to question it in light of other possible views, and then, with new questions in hand, to explore other possible answers.
Enrolled
Required Texts
For the FIRST PAPER, you may either:
For some, but not all, of these topics, I have particular sources in mind from which you should start your research. I'll bring them to your attention when you select the topic.
FIRST PAPER TOPIC SELECTION: February 26
FIRST PAPER IS DUE March 19 (hard-copy)
For the SECOND PAPER, select a topic from the following LIST. The paper will take two forms:
a 10-15 minute presentation to the seminar
A highly recommended source to use at the outset of your research is Ellen Reeder, Pandora: Women in Classical Greece, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1995 (on Reserve). See the BIBLIOGRAPHY for additional sources.
When complete and online, you will make a presentation of your report to the seminar. Each presentation should be approximately 10-15 minutes long, with additional time allowed for discussion and questions.
SECOND PAPER TOPIC SELECTION: April 2
SECOND PAPER IS DUE April 23 (in Microsoft Word on a Macintosh disk)
Both papers should comprise a discussion and analysis of your chosen topic focusing in particular on issues of identity and interpretation. They should be researched as extensively as possible using both library and online resources.
Grading
Office Hours
The seminar examines how women have been represented in art in the
Ancient World, how these images have been interpreted over time, and
how they might be (re-)interpreted in the light of new, mostly feminist,
critical approaches and perspectives on the past that have emerged in
recent years.
Our understanding of the Prehistoric and Ancient past is colored by various points of view. Anyone living in the United States at the end of the 20th century necessarily has a Euro-American or "western" worldview that is largely the product of prevailing white, male, Judaeo-Christian values and attitudes. It is important to understand that there are other worldviews not only in different parts of the world, but also at different times in history.
To a large extent, the seminar is conceived as being less a course of study of already familiar and "pre-digested" material than as an exploration of a series of fundamental questions about familiar objects and images. The aim is to seek out possible alternative readings of images of women in the ancient world. There are no clear answers to these questions. Your instructor does not necessarily "know" the answers, nor does he expect you simply to "learn" whatever answers are encountered in the seminar.
Requirements
You are required to research and write TWO 8-10 page papers.
or
a webpage with text, images, links, and bibliography
Wherever possible, your text should be "annotated" with links to further information. A list of websites with additional information should be added, as well as a bibliography listing books and articles you have used (in addition to Baring and Cashford). Include as many illustrations (either actual images, or links to images) as you wish. How this is done will be explained later.
Significant contribution to discussion in the seminar is expected and will be graded.
Regular Attendance is required at all class meetings, scheduled events, and field trips listed in the syllabus. Attendance will be taken and used to determine the final grade. If you cannot attend a class meeting, scheduled event, or field trip, you must inform me in advance. Each unexplained absence from a class meeting, scheduled event, or field trip will result in a lowering of your grade.![]()
Any requirements not fulfilled at the end of the semester will result in a notice of failure for the course![]()
FIRST PAPER = 35%
SECOND PAPER = 45%
CONTRIBUTION / ATTENDANCE = 20%
Tuesdays and Wednesdays, 1:15-2:15
Otherwise, I can be reached at my office, Benedict 310 (knock, if my door is closed), of telephoned (381 6194), or faxed (381 6494), or emailed: witcombe@sbc.edu
Chris
Witcombe | Sweet Briar College